Arboricultural Impact Assessment vs Tree Management Plan vs Tree Protection Plan

Nick Buckley

Choose the right arborist report the first time, avoid council back-and-forth, and protect your project timeline.


You’ll learn what each document does, when councils usually ask for it, how they work together, and how to pick the right one based on your project stage.



  • AIA = impact and viability after the build
  • TMP = construction rules for working near trees
  • TPP = scaled plan showing protection measures on site


The quick difference (plain English)

Arboricultural Impact Assessment (AIA)

An Arboricultural Impact Assessment looks at how a proposed design could affect existing trees, and what needs to change or be managed so trees can remain viable after construction.

Read more on Arboricultural Impact Assessment.



Tree Management Plan (TMP)

A Tree Management Plan is the practical rulebook for the build. It sets out how to work near retained trees during demolition, excavation, and construction, without causing avoidable damage.

Read more on Tree Management Plan.



Tree Protection Plan (TPP)

A Tree Protection Plan is a scaled drawing that shows the protection measures on the site plan, including tree locations, protection zones, and where fencing and controls go.

Read more on Tree Protection Plan.



When each report is needed

Use this as a decision shortcut

Most projects fit one of these patterns:


  • Design and approvals stage: Start with an AIA to confirm impacts, constraints, and what needs to change before plans are locked in.
  • Permit conditions stage: Add a TMP when council wants a clear method for protecting retained trees during works.
  • On-site setup stage: Use a TPP so everyone on site can see the protection layout at a glance.


Ordering the right report at the right stage is one of the simplest ways to reduce delays.


Why councils ask for different documents

Councils are usually trying to answer three questions:



  • Will the proposed works damage trees, or cause decline later?
  • What controls will stop avoidable damage during construction?
  • Can the protection measures be verified on site?


AIA, TMP, and TPP line up to those three questions.


What each document typically includes

AIA inclusions

An AIA commonly covers:



  • Tree condition and retention considerations
  • Potential impacts from the proposed works
  • Protection zones and key constraints
  • Practical recommendations to reduce risk to tree viability post-construction
  • Approval considerations relevant to the scope


An AIA is the “can this design work near these trees” document.


TMP inclusions

A TMP commonly covers:



  • Site rules for working within protection zones
  • Access routes, storage areas, and no-go zones
  • Methods to reduce root damage during excavation and construction
  • Timing and sequencing recommendations around high-risk works
  • Monitoring and supervision requirements where needed for compliance


A TMP is the “how the site will behave around trees” document.


TPP inclusions

A TPP is typically a scaled plan showing:



  • Accurate tree locations
  • Tree Protection Zones and Structural Root Zones
  • Fencing and signage locations
  • Ground protection areas (where needed)
  • Any other protection measures noted in the TMP


A TPP is the “show it on the plan” document.


How they work together on real projects

Example 1, home extension near established trees

  • AIA confirms whether the footprint and excavation will likely cause unacceptable impacts.
  • TMP sets the rules for demolition, excavation, and site access around retained trees.
  • TPP shows fencing and protection on the plan so the builder can set it up correctly.



Example 2, multi-dwelling or townhouse development

  • AIA is used early to prevent redesign later, especially where trees constrain setbacks, driveways, or services.
  • TMP is often required as a permit condition to keep the build compliant.
  • TPP reduces on-site confusion, especially with multiple trades and changing site conditions.



Example 3, approvals are done, but the site needs compliance controls

  • TMP + TPP can be the priority set, particularly where the key risk is construction-stage damage.
  • 

The standard that often sits behind tree protection on development sites

Tree protection on development sites is commonly guided by the Australian Standard AS 4970:2025, which sets out principles and processes for retaining and protecting trees during development.


Link: AS 4970:2025 Protection of trees on development sites

This matters because it creates a shared language across planning, consulting arborists, and construction teams, including terms like Tree Protection Zone and Structural Root Zone.



FAQs

What is the difference between an arborist report and an AIA?

“Arborist report” is a broad term that can mean several document types, depending on what council or the project needs. An Arboricultural Impact Assessment (AIA) is a specific report focused on how a proposed design and construction impacts existing trees, and what controls or design changes are needed to retain them.



A practical way to think about it:

  • Arborist report = the umbrella term
  • AIA = the impact-focused report used to support design and approvals


Can a Tree Protection Plan be included within another report?

Yes, a TPP is often included as a plan within a Tree Management Plan, or attached as an appendix. Some councils or permit conditions prefer it as a standalone plan so it can be issued to builders and displayed on site without the full report.


If the scope is construction-stage compliance, a clear pairing is:



Do I need a TMP if my works are outside the Tree Protection Zone?

Often, if all works and site activities are genuinely outside the Tree Protection Zone, a TMP may not be required. The common issue is that “works” includes more than just the finished footprint.


A TMP can still be relevant if there will be:

  • Access routes, turning circles, or temporary works near trees
  • Material storage, washout, or spoil placement near protection zones
  • Trenching for services that passes near trees
  • Compaction risks from repeated vehicle movement
  • Changes in levels, drainage, or soil conditions near root zones
  • 

When should tree protection fencing go in?

Tree protection fencing should be installed before any activity that could affect the tree area, including demolition, excavation, earthworks, or bringing heavy machinery onto site. It is normally set up after the site is set-out and verified, then kept in place and maintained for the duration of high-risk works.



What site information is needed to prepare a TPP accurately?

A TPP is only as good as the drawings and site information behind it. The usual inputs include:



  • Current feature and level survey
  • Proposed site plan and architectural drawings
  • Civil drawings, including levels, drainage, and pavement build-ups (if applicable)
  • Tree locations and identifiers that match the consultant’s assessment
  • Proposed access routes, laydown areas, and scaffolding zones
  • Any known service runs, trenching routes, and piering locations
  • Construction staging, especially where protection needs to change over time


Common mistakes

Ordering the wrong document first

The most common delay is starting with a TMP or TPP when the design still has major conflicts. If the footprint is not viable, the project can loop back into redesign.



Treating a tree protection plan like a generic site note

A TPP needs to match the actual site layout and construction method. If fencing and access routes are vague, it becomes hard to enforce on site.



Inconsistent tree numbering across plans

When the AIA, architectural drawings, and TPP do not match tree IDs, it creates instant confusion for planners, builders, and site supervisors.



Starting works before tree protection is installed

Even small early works can cause root damage. Once roots are compromised, the rest of the documentation may not prevent decline.



Ignoring permit conditions and staging

Some approvals require specific steps at set points in the build. Missing the timing can trigger stop-work actions or rework.


Avoidable compliance issues are usually process issues, not tree issues.



Quick checklist and next steps

Checklist, before you brief an arborist

  • Confirm your project stage: concept design, lodged, approved, or on-site.
  • Confirm who the decision-maker is: council planner, private certifier, or project superintendent.
  • Gather current drawings: site plan, floor plans, proposed levels, driveway and service runs.
  • Identify the high-risk works: excavation, demolition, piering, trenching, or grade changes.
  • Confirm what council is actually asking for: AIA, TMP, TPP, or a combination.


What to do next


Wrap-up

AIA, TMP, and TPP are different tools for different moments in the project. The clean approach is simple, assess impacts early, lock in controls before works start, and make the on-site layout unmissable.



Enquire
Use the contact form to confirm which report your project needs and what to prepare before a site visit.


All Posts

Share Post:

Ready to work with TMC Reports?

Let's connect! We’re here to help.

Send us a message and we’ll be in touch. 

Or give us a call today at 0401 442 604

Agency Contact Form


More Marketing Tips, Tricks & Tools


By Nick Buckley March 5, 2026
If you’re planning to remove, destroy or lop a tree on your property as of September 15 2025, this is a big change you need to know about. A new statewide planning provision (Clause 52.37) has officially come into effect introducing new rules for tree removal and canopy cover on residential land across Victoria. In other words, tree protection laws just got tougher. Many property owners will now need a planning permit to remove, lop ‘canopy trees’. Even if they are on your land. So what does that mean for you? Let’s break down what Clause 52.37 actually covers , who it applies to , and how to stay compliant without getting buried in paperwork. Where Clause 52.37 Applies The new rules apply to residential land within the following planning zones: Mixed Use Zone (MUZ) Township Zone (TZ) Residential Growth Zone (RGZ) General Residential Zone (GRZ) Neighbourhood Residential Zone (NRZ) Housing Choice and Transport Zone (HCTZ) If your property sits in one of these zones and you plan to remove or significantly prune a tree, the new permit requirements likely apply. What Counts as a “Canopy Tree”? This is where the details matter. Under Clause 52.37, a “Canopy Tree” is defined as a tree that meets all three of these triggers: Height greater than 5 metres A single trunk circumference greater than 0.5 metres, measured 1.4 metres above ground level Canopy diameter of at least 4 metres Things to consider For a tree to be considered a canopy tree, it must tick all three of the above boxes. For example, if a tree is greater than 5m in height, has a canopy diameter of greater than 4m but does not have a single trunk circumference greater than 0.5m. It will not be considered a canopy tree, and will not need a permit to remove, destroy or lop. Another important note is that a canopy tree needs to be ‘greater’ than the above dimensions. Meaning if a tree is 5m in height exactly it will not need a permit. It needs to be 5.1m in height to tick that box. When You Need a Permit (and When You Don’t) Clause 52.37 sets clear rules for when a planning permit is required to remove, lop, or destroy a tree. If the site is vacant without a dwelling, you will need a permit to remove destroy or lop a tree that ticks the above 3 boxes anywhere within the site. If the site has an existing residential dwelling situated on it, you will need a permit to remove, destroy or lop a tree that ticks the above 3 boxes within the front 6m and the rear 4.5m (see below images).
A mature deciduous tree in a suburban yard shows signs of distress with a large vertical crack in it
By Nick Buckley August 23, 2025
Not sure if your tree needs to go? Catch the warning signs early and avoid costly damage or fines with expert advice and council-ready reports from TMC Reports.
A large tree stands in a suburban backyard with a wooden fence and two brick houses in the backgroun
By Nick Buckley August 22, 2025
Need to remove a tree? TMC Reports explains when council approval is required and how arborist reports help you avoid fines, delays, or rejected permits.